POV
The Frightened
Forest - Petersburg H.S
10/26/2009
We are the Frightened Forest and we feel threatened
by the overwhelming abundance of
deer. They ruthlessly masticate the helpless
Ginseng, while neglecting the populous ferns
that hog the sunlight and choke the lives of
innocent plants (Roach 2005). The savage
beasts slaughter the forest and offer nothing but
malevolence. Something must be done.
Allow us to explain our animosity toward these
barbarians. It wasn’t always this way.
When the deer first migrated into our lush green
forests, we very much enjoyed their
nibbling, which helped control our plant growth.
Within a short time span, we began to
notice, although the ferns were prospering, our much
more important vegetations were
being diminished before our eyes. Consider Ginseng:
these plants are not only essential to
us, but also to the 10,000 people in West Virginia
alone that harvest them. The tips of
these leaves are ferociously damaged by deer, making
their survival less likely. “Using
computer models, the researchers concluded that,
should the deer-foraging trend continue,
the over-two-century-old Appalachian ginseng
harvest tradition will soon end.” (Roach
2005)
Another problem these savages have caused in our
lands is the destruction of trees. Tree
seedlings used to be able to survive peacefully
under the canopy of our dense branches. It
turns out that the monsters particularly enjoy these
saplings (Warner 2005). If this
continues, will there ever be new trees? The usually
joyous White Cedar tree have turned
brown with melancholy. The deer enjoy eating the
bark so much, they have eaten off of
nearly every White Cedar in our forest (Forest Foods
Deer Eat 2009).
In conclusion, we demand that action be taken
against these beasts. They are terrorizing
our green communities. For the sake of all beings,
hear our cry. Propose to take action with
us, and help control deer population, before it
controls us.
References Cited
Forest Foods Deer Eat. Department of Natural
Resources. 2009.
http://www.michigan.gov/dnr/0,1607,7-153-10370_12148-61306--,00.html
Ginseng-Hungry Deer Eating Appalachian Tradition.
Roach, John. 2005.
http://news.nationalgeographic.com/news/2005/03/0314_050314_ginseng.html
Notes on White-tail Deer Populations in WV. Warner,
David. 2005.
http://www.cacaponinstitute.org/html/CI%20E-classroom/Warner_Deer.html
Ask a Thoughtful Question or Respond
Thoughtful Questions
From:
Where my home is at ! - Other Stakeholder - HHS
Statement
11/5/2009
9:57:00 AM
You don't have to fence in an entire forest. Just areas
that are being seriously
destroyed. It doesn't have to be the entire area,
either. People that want to help can just
go in their backyard(as long as there is a forest), and
put up a fence to help grow trees
and other forest floor plants. We have a fenced in area
at our school and it seems to be
working. If the deer eat all of the Ginseng, there won't
be a sport of hunting for it at all.
People might have to resort to growing it in a fenced
area if that does happen.
Response
The Frightened Forest - forest - PHS
11/17/2009
7:30:00 AM
How do you plan to provide the monetary necessities that
would accompany these
fences? Keep in mind that these vivacious deer can
easily leap over fences, so
you are implying that we need to also provide a roofing.
This is not logical
because the trees need room to grow, and the 'fencing'
would need to resemble a
greenhouse makeup to accomodate the trees needs.
From:
squirrel huggers - forest - EHHS
Statement
11/4/2009
8:28:00 AM
All the questons you have asked about Ginseng arent
really well thought out are they. You
have resources, so look the the uses of Ginseng up, It
has lots of medical uses, if you
would research it we are sure you will see the light,
and understand more fully the reason
we have stuck it into our papers.
From:
Save the Deer - Other Stakeholder - NHHS
Ask
11/3/2009
1:01:00 PM
Couldn't deer resistant plants be planted in or near the
forest?
From:
Where my home is at ! - Other Stakeholder - HHS
Statement
10/29/2009
9:14:00 AM
The deer are eating plants in the same areas because
people moved in and cut/cleared all
the trees and land. They don’t have as much of an area
to eat in. They wouldn’t need to
feed in the same areas and destroy the smaller plants if
it wasn’t for us. Have people
tried growing Ginseng in protected areas where the deer
can’t eat it? That could be an
alternative for the people that collect it. Then they
wouldn’t have to worry about it as
much. And as many people have pointed out in their
postings, trees can be fenced in.
The fence doesn’t have to be super high, just high
enough. And other animals are eating
the trees, don’t just blame the deer.
Response
The Frightened Forest - forest - PHS
10/30/2009
6:39:00 AM
Have you ever tried fencing in an entire forest of
trees? With a 6 foot
fence, which deer are still capable of jumping? Doesn't
work. Also, in
regards of the ginseng, people simply don't want it
confined by fence.
Citizens have made a sport of hunting Ginseng, just as
they made a sport of
hunting deer. Keep in consideration that if they
attempted to grow it in
captivity, industries would monopolize the growth of
ginseng. Consequently,
the people who have once relied on ginseng for a
constant income will suffer.
From:
squirrel huggers - forest - EHHS
Statement
10/29/2009
7:42:00 AM
We agee very strongly with Frightened forest statements
about the Ginseng, we also put
something in our paper about it. The deer threaten the
survival and as a medicine in
todays enviorment, well you cant really waste it can
you? We more than wholeheartedly
agree with you. very good point
Response
The Frightened Forest - forest - PHS
10/30/2009
6:40:00 AM
We appreciate your support. May the forest be with you.
From:
JJCFARM - farmer - BGHS
Ask
10/26/2009
9:08:00 AM
how will you manage the deer population. why do you
harvest ginseng
Response
The Frightened Forest - forest - PHS
10/28/2009
6:26:00 AM
We will control deer population with the help of home
owners, farmers, and
hunters. With cooperation, we can quarantine these
beasts.Ginseng: An herb
that has been used to stimulate the adrenal gland and
thereby increase energy. It
also may have some beneficial effect on reducing blood
sugar in patients with
diabetes mellitus. It is used in medicine and energy
drinks. Also, it is used as a
tonic for people with fatigue, poor appetite, shortness
of breath and low
resistance to infections.